Taking a look at the Applause Index I noticed that most of the 60 bellwether apps (find out how these apps were chosen) have very similar Applause Scores for both their iOS and Android versions. While a few points difference is to be expected, 12 of these popular apps have a 20+ point discrepancy between OSes.
iOS vs. Android Applause Score
- Wikipedia Mobile: 27 vs. 62
- The Wall Street Journal: 58 vs. 33
- Spotify: 79 vs. 44
- Facebook: 50 vs. 26
- OpenTable: 93 vs. 63
- Yahoo! Mail: 57 vs. 31
- Expedia Hotels: 64 vs. 40
- TOTALe Companion: 36 vs. 13
- My Xbox LIVE: 65 vs. 34
- Angry Birds Free: 83 vs. 51
- ESPN ScoreCenter: 35 vs. 55
The worst quality gap is Spotify, with a 36 point difference. Spotify does a decent job of pleasing users with its iOS app, but when it comes to Android they need to step up their game. Satisfaction takes the biggest hit, but that’s to be expected considering all 10 Applause Attributes have much lower Android scores than iOS scores. Elegance sees one of the biggest drops between the two operating systems. While some people are pleased with the app’s appearance, a large portion find the app unappealing. While the Usability ratings for the iOS version tend to stick to the higher side, Android users are all over the place. When it comes to Android Usability, Spotify doesn’t have one glaring issue, but it’s not really pleasing anyone in any usability factor. Spotify needs to look into its overall mobile login and password procedures – it’s a problem for both platforms and a major driver of one-star ratings.
ESPN ScoreCenter almost escaped being on this list with only a 20 point difference. While the Android version surpasses some user expectations, there are some big pitfalls with the iOS version. Elegance takes the biggest hit. While Android users think the app’s elegance is about average (with a mix of people liking it, disliking it and feeling indifferent), iOS users almost all fall on the side of dislike. One-star reviews dominate this attribute signal for iOS. Content also takes a dive. While star ratings are spread out for both versions, the one-star side is definitely heavier on iOS. Android isn’t perfect though – one glaring issue is an apparent problem with localization.
Since nine of the 11 apps on this list have higher rated iOS versions it could be that these brands are falling victim to the development and testing challenges of Android. But considering the other 48 apps on the Applause Index have much closer quality levels, that’s not much of an excuse.















